Law Office of Yvonne Garbett · DWI defense

One mistake doesn’t define you.

After a DWI arrest, the questions can feel relentless: Will I be able to drive? What do I tell my family? What happens when I go to court? We understand that this is scary. At the Law Office of Yvonne Garbett, you are a person with a life to protect, not just a charge on a calendar. We represent clients in Rockland, Orange and Westchester Counties with a thoughtful, strategic defense built around the evidence and what matters to you. An accusation does not establish guilt, and this moment does not have to define who you are.

Yvonne brings 24 years as an attorney, admitted in 2002: Rockland Assistant District Attorney (2002–2006), Rockland Assistant Public Defender (2013–2015) and private defense since 2006.

A defense built around your life

  1. 01

    Begin with your concerns, not assumptions

    What are you most afraid of losing — your ability to drive to work, time with your children, or the stability you have worked to build? We listen to your account and use those priorities to help shape a practical defense. Being charged does not mean the prosecution has proved its case.

  2. 02

    Reconstruct what actually happened

    A police report is one account, not the whole story. We compare it with available recordings, witness recollections and testing records, looking at the sequence from the initial stop through the arrest. Details that seemed unimportant that night may matter now.

  3. 03

    Turn unanswered questions into a legal strategy

    We examine the grounds for the stop, the way questioning was conducted and the reliability of the testing. Where the facts support it, we ask the court to exclude improperly obtained evidence. A challenge must fit your case; it is not a promise that evidence will be excluded.

  4. 04

    Keep your daily life in the conversation

    Court obligations and driving restrictions can affect an entire household. We explain the issues that may arise, discuss the separate DMV process and consider how different resolutions could affect your work and family responsibilities.

  5. 05

    Weigh an offer before making a decision

    A lesser-sounding charge is not always a lesser consequence. We look beyond the label to points, license restrictions and other conditions, then discuss the tradeoffs with you. You deserve to understand what a proposed plea would mean before deciding.

  6. 06

    Prepare for the path your case requires

    Some cases resolve through negotiation; others require hearings or trial. Our preparation is guided by the evidence and your circumstances, with clear explanations along the way. We work toward the strongest available resolution without guaranteeing a result.

Confidential consultation · Available 24/7

Case intake

Tell us about your case before your consultation. All fields are confidential.

Is this for a criminal case or a Family Court matter?

In the news & court decisions

Jury acquits Yvonne Garbett’s client of all charges

Hudson Valley One reported that New Paltz police officer Jerome Milton, charged with official misconduct and filing a false report among other crimes, was found not guilty by a jury in June 2026. Yvonne Garbett was his trial attorney.

Read the article (Hudson Valley One, June 14, 2026)

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

View the print edition (June 17, 2026, PDF)

Case dismissed on speedy-trial grounds (CPL § 30.30)

In People v. Vasquez, 2024 NY Slip Op 51629(U), the Town of Haverstraw Justice Court (Rockland County) granted Yvonne Garbett’s motion and dismissed the case on December 2, 2024. The court held that an adjournment caused by the assigned judge’s illness counts against the prosecution, a question it described as one of first impression.

Read the decision (Justia)
Read the decision (FindLaw)

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

These published matters illustrate case-specific defense work; they are not predictions of a DWI result.

Understand the charge before deciding what comes next

The different impaired-driving charges under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law §1192 do not all require the same proof. A BAC of .08% or higher can support a per-se DWI charge; a separate DWI provision concerns intoxication established through other evidence. That means the absence of a chemical result does not necessarily end a prosecution. We explain which provision you are accused of violating and what the prosecution must establish.

Alcohol affects people differently. Food intake, body characteristics, the amount consumed and the time involved all influence its effects. A rough estimate such as “one drink an hour” is not a dependable way to decide whether you can drive safely or are below a legal limit. We focus on the evidence in your case rather than assumptions about how someone should have appeared or felt.

DWAI by alcohol concerns impaired driving ability, rather than the higher level of intoxication associated with DWI. A BAC above .05% and no higher than .07% may be evidence of that impairment; it is not the only issue to consider. Other §1192 provisions address drugs or a combination of drugs and alcohol. For drivers under 21, the .02%–.07% Zero Tolerance range involves a separate administrative DMV process, not an automatic criminal DWI conviction.

VTL §1192 — Impaired-driving offenses

Your license, your responsibilities and the possible consequences

For many clients, the hardest part is not knowing how a case could interrupt everyday life. The ranges below outline common penalties under VTL §1193; they are not a prediction of your sentence. The exact charge, prior history and circumstances matter. A chemical-test refusal also raises separate DMV issues that must be considered alongside the criminal case.

DWI, first offense (misdemeanor)
Up to 1 year in jail, $500–$1,000 fine, license revoked at least 6 months, 11 DMV points
DWI, second within 10 years (class E felony)
Up to 4 years, $1,000–$5,000 fine, revocation at least 1 year, 11 DMV points
DWI, third within 10 years (class D felony)
Up to 7 years, $2,000–$10,000 fine, revocation at least 1 year, 11 DMV points
DWAI (alcohol), first offense (traffic infraction)
Up to 15 days in jail, $300–$500 fine, 90-day suspension, 11 DMV points
DWAI, second within 5 years
Up to 30 days in jail, $500–$750 fine, revocation at least 6 months, 11 DMV points
DWAI, third within 10 years (misdemeanor)
Up to 180 days in jail, $750–$1,500 fine, revocation at least 6 months, 11 DMV points

A change many people don’t know about: since February 16, 2026, every conviction under VTL §1192 — DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI and DWAI-Drugs — adds 11 points to your New York driving record. Before that date these convictions carried no points at all, because the DMV handled them through mandatory suspension or revocation instead. The new points apply based on the date of the offense: violations on or after February 16, 2026 get the new values; earlier violations keep the old ones.

This matters even more if you already have points on your record. The DMV can now call you to a suspension hearing at 10 points within 24 months — the old rule was 11 points in 18 months — so a single DWI or DWAI conviction is enough on its own to trigger that hearing, and it can tip you over the line when combined with older speeding or other tickets. The points come on top of the statutory suspension or revocation, not instead of it, and 6 or more points also trigger a Driver Responsibility Assessment fee. Driving while your license is suspended or revoked (Aggravated Unlicensed Operation, VTL §511) now carries 11 points too, and the number of impaired-driving convictions that can lead to a lifetime revocation has dropped from five to four.

It also changes how a case should be negotiated. Pleading a DWI down to a DWAI used to avoid points entirely — it no longer does. That makes the details of any plea offer, and the possibility of a non-§1192 resolution, more important than ever, and it’s one of the first things we look at when we plan your defense.

The figures above do not capture every possible obligation. Surcharges, ignition-interlock requirements and other conditions may apply. Aggravated DWI carries its own requirements, while an incident involving injury or death may lead to additional charges such as vehicular assault or vehicular manslaughter. We discuss those issues without losing sight of the practical worries — employment, household expenses and family commitments — that brought you to us.

VTL §1193 — Sanctions · NY DMV — Alcohol and drug-related penalties · NY DMV — Driver point system

An arrest leaves questions. A careful defense investigates them.

Does the evidence justify the initial encounter?

We compare the officer’s stated reason for stopping you with the available evidence and the legal standard that applies. A reported driving pattern should be examined, not simply accepted. An unlawful stop may provide grounds to seek suppression of evidence.

What happened before you answered questions?

We review when and how questioning occurred, whether it amounted to custodial interrogation, and whether required Miranda warnings were given. Those distinctions matter: not every roadside question requires a warning, and a violation does not automatically dismiss the entire case.

What supports the reported test result?

A number on a report needs a reliable foundation. Maintenance and calibration records, operator qualifications, testing procedures and the handling of a blood sample can all deserve scrutiny. We assess whether a problem supports an evidentiary challenge or undermines the prosecution’s proof.

Do the recordings and recollections tell the same story?

We look for differences between an officer’s written account, testimony and available video. The circumstances in which an observation was made can be just as important as the observation itself.

Has your health and physical condition been considered?

Illness, injury, fatigue or a medical condition may help explain conduct described as a sign of intoxication. Medication also requires careful analysis because drug-related impairment can itself be charged. An alternative explanation must be supported by the facts, not assumed.

These are areas for investigation, not a checklist that guarantees dismissal. The prosecution must prove the charged criminal offense beyond a reasonable doubt; DMV proceedings use different standards. We assess what the evidence can establish, explain where a challenge may help and work with you toward the best available outcome in your circumstances.

You deserve clarity, not pressure

Starting early gives us an opportunity to identify available recordings, locate witnesses and address time-sensitive court and DMV issues. You do not need to have everything figured out before contacting us. We can begin with what you know and help you understand the next step.

DWI charges and definitions · Early defense & treatment alternatives

Attorney advertising. General information, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Text us for immediate helpCall now